Information compiled by
Wayne Sinclair, M.D. (Board Certified Immunology)
Richard Pressinger, M.Ed.
FOOD PESTICIDE APPLICATIONS
MEDICAL JOURNAL PESTICIDE TOXICOLOGY SUMMARIESarchers stated,
SOURCE: Environmental Health Perspectives
Childhood asthma is the most common chronic disease among U.S. children and is the leading cause of death as measured by hospitalizations and school absences. In a report from the CDC, the percentage of people with asthma increased 75% from 1980 to 1994 in the U.S.. When looking at only children ages 0-4, their rates increased 160% (from about 22 per 1,000 to 58 per 1000 children). Looking back even further, it is difficult to get asthma rates as it was quite rare before 1970. For example, in 1960, only about 1% of the people in the United Kingdom consulted doctors for asthma (Thorax 2007). Today in the UK, rates are similar to that in the U.S. and have risen to about 9% of children and 8% of adults. As asthma rates have skyrocketed since the 1960's, this suggests environmental factors may be working individually or together to increase asthma rates.
Several studies have linked exposure to pesticides with asthma and asthma related symptoms. A study of 93 farm workers found that exposure to pesticides in the preceding year resulted in increased wheezing. To understand this next study, it is important to first understand the immune system-asthma connection: Asthma is characterized by chronic inflammation in the airways and is accomopanied by elevated numbers of T helper 2 immune system cells that produce compounds known as interleukins. These interleukins bring about an asthma attack by attracting eosinophils and mast cells to the airwarys. On the opposite side, the immune system also has what is called T helper 1 cells. These T helper 1 cells produce interferon and is believed to protect against asthma. Studies of patients with allergies and asthma show they have elevated levels of the "bad" T Helper 2 cytokines interleukin-4 and interleukin-5 and abnormally low levels of interferon and tumor necrosis factor produced by the "good" T helper 1 immune system cells. This brings into question on how pesticides can have an immunotoxic effect and alter normal levels of these critical asthma regulating compounds.
In his study, scientists studied 239 children living in the Salinas Valley agricultural area for relationships between environmental exposures during the first 12 months of life and levels of the "good" T helper 1 interferons and "bad" T helper 2 interleukins (since these are related to asthma). They measured levels of these "good" and "bad" compounds in children when they were 24 months old. Results showed that wheezing was significantly higher in asthmatic children if they had ligher levels of the "bad" T helper 2 compounds. Along with this, children whose mothers worked in agriculture had a 25.9% increase in the "bad" T helper 2 compounds. Along with the suspected pesticide exposure, gas stoves in the home were also found to increase the "bad" T helper 2 compounds while breast feeding increased levels of the "good" T helper 1 compounds.
COMMENT: As asthma rates in children continue to increase (along with the potential for death from asthma), studies such as this strongly support the contention that alternatives to chemical pesticides in homes and schools should be implemented and chemical pesticides phased out as soon as possible.
Center for Children's Environmental Health
As mentioned above, childhood asthma has increased dramatically over the past 50+ years, affecting less than 1% of children before 1960 and nearly 9% in 2010. Studies of historical child asthma rates suggest only 1/2% of children were affected prior to 1950. If this is correct, child asthma rates today are about 18 times higher than in the 1930's & 40's. These studies can be seen in the April 2006 journal THORAX. In a 2010 CDC report, asthma was reported to affect nearly 8% of white children and 12% of black children. These dramatic increases in asthma strongly suggests environmental factors are responsible and stresses the importance of conducting research investigating asthma and how it relates to exposure to different environmental factors.
To address this question, researchers at the Department of Preventive Medicine at University of Southern California, investigated environmental exposures among 4,000 children previously diagnosed with asthma before age 5 and compared their environmental exposures to asthma free children. Most of the children were white and male with middle income status. Below are the results of their study.
Farm Crops Doubles Risk of Asthma
Department of Preventive Medicine
Wheezing at 4 years of age was higher in children whose mothers had higher levels of DDE when tested during the birth of their child. Asthma was defined based on wheezing at 4 years of age or by doctor-diagnosed asthma. 405 children were tested for DDE exposure from levels in the mother's umbilical cord at birth. Children were then divided into four groups from low to high DDE exposure. Children in the highest quartile had an asthma rate of 19% while children in the lowest DDE quartile had an astma rate of 9%.
Researchers believe two pathways (immune or hormonal) could be involved in the increased asthma rates in children. DDT has been shown to change the numbers and functions of immune system cells and also interferes with hormonal receptors and mimics estrogen activity.
People in the U.S. are exposed to DDE by eating foods imported from other countries. For example, a large percentage of produce is imported into the U.S. during the winter from countries that still use DDT (ie. South America/Africa). DDE exposure can also occur from indoor air of older homes and from living near farms in the U.S. using the pesticide Kelthane (dicofol) which contains DDT as a by-product. DDT is also used in Africa and other countries for malaria control.
Dept of Occupational & Environmental Medicine,
SOURCE: Environmental Health Perspectives, Vol. 115(70):1482-1489, October 2007
Living close to agriculture was found to significantly increase the risk of a mother having a child with Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD). 465 children with ASD were compared to 7,000 control children in California. Living distance from food crops using pesticides was measured. Researchers then determined the mother's pesticide exposure for each 30 day window throughout pregnancy using mandatory state reported pesticide application data.
While families living more than 1 mile from agriculture showed no increase in Autism Spectrum Disorder, families living less than 1 mile of agriculture showed a significant increase in ASD. This risk of ASD then jumped to 7.6 times above normal if families lived less than 500 meters (about 1/3rd mile) from farming areas and when certain pesticides were applied from day 26 to day 88 of pregnancy. Researchers believe this 2 month developmental period from day 26 to 88 is a critical window of neurological development in the unborn child and a time that the developing brain is far more sensitive to harm than other time periods in pregnancy.
Chem-Tox Comment: Of interest is the time period of pesticide exposure that resulted in greatly increased ASD is also the time period during pregnancy that the human brain begins growing at over 4,000 cells per second (one-quarter million per minute).
School of Public Health
SOURCE: Human Experimental Toxicology, Vol. 18(3):174-9, March, 1999
The human brain is protected from harm by a defense system known as the blood brain barrier. The first stage of the blood brain barrier is made from exceptionally "tight-junctions" between cells that line the blood vessels supplying nutrients to the brain. These tight-junctions prevent larger toxic molecules from squeezing-through and entering the brain cell network. Unfortunately, the tight-junctions can become "lose" after exposure to some chemicals in the environment - thereby, allowing toxic chemicals into the brain cell network with potential for causing elevated damage to the brain. Chemicals now being found to damage the blood brain barrier take on new interest as research over the past decade has found defects in blood brain barrier function in people with Psychosis(1), Epilepsy(2), Alzheimer's(3) and Parkinson's Disease(4).
In this 1999 research, scientists exposed 10 day old rat pups to three separate pesticides. This included quinalphos (an organophosphate pesticide) - cypermethrin (a pyrethoid pesticide) and the chemical Lindane (an organochlorine pesticide). Exposure levels were 1/50th the amount that would kill 50% of the animals. To determine if the pesticides were damaging the blood brain barrier, animals were injected with a radioactive tracer. Normally, the tracer would be blocked by the blood brain barrier and not enter the brain. However, 2 hours after exposure to the pesticides, the tracer had entered the brain, thereby demonstrating blood brain barrier dysfunction. The three pesticides had disrupted blood brain barrier permeability by 130, 80, and 50% respectively. Defects in blood brain barrier function was also seen at exposure levels of only 1/100th the amount needed to kill 50% of the animals. Of significant interest, 15 day old rat pups had less barrier damage than the 10 day old rat pups. Adult rats showed no evidence of blood brain barrier damage whatsoever. Extrapolating these results to humans, we would then expect younger children to receive far more harm from pesticide exposure than adolescents or adults. Unfortunately, safe levels of pesticides exposure are currently set from research done with healthy adult animals.
1. British Journal of Psychiatry Volume 141(3):273-281, September, 1982
SOURCE: International Journal of Developmental Neuroscience
Scientists in Lucknow, India have found that the blood-brain barrier is damaged by ingredients typically used in mosquito repellents. A quick science lesson - The blood brain barrier is basically a "wall" that protects the brain from damage that would otherwise occur from the many toxic compounds in our blood. Without a properly working blood brain barrier, the brain malfunctions - resulting in a variety of neurological conditions.
Scientists tested for blood brain barrier damage using a common over-the-counter mosquito repellent containing a 3.6% solution of the pyrethroid pesticide - allethrin. Their previous work had shown that bug sprays caused significant blood brain barrier damage to newborn rat pups (Link). The current study was designed to find out what types of blood brain barrier damage would occur if exposure occurred at different times during development.
Since humans could not be directly tested using this procedure - scientists exposed "rat pups" to the mosquito/bug spray early in pregnancy and also just before and after birth. They used what is called a micromolecular tracer to determine if it "leaked" into the brain after pesticide exposure. Results showed exposure during any of the three time periods resulted in significant break-down of the animals' blood brain barrier. Also of concern, it was found that damage persisted when tested one week after exposure. The scientists concluded by stating,
The results suggest that Mosquito Repellent inhalation during early prenatal - postnatal - perinatal life may have adverse effects on infants leading to central nervous system (CNS) abnormalities, if a mechanism operates in humans similar to that in rat pups.
Chem-Tox Comment: This study is of particular concern for the following reasons:
Developmental Toxicology Division
SOURCE: Environmental Health Perspectives, Volume 119(8): 1196-120`, April 21, 2011
265 early elementary school children were found to score lower on tests of learning and memory if their mothers had higher levels of a common pesticide. Children were selected from low-income communities in New York City. During delivery, umbilical cord blood samples were taken from the mothers and tested for a common pesticide. The pesticide is used in agriculture and hundreds of gallons per home was applied as a termite barrier in homes built before 2000. Exposure can also occur from non-organic food sources when importing food from other countries.
After 7 years, their children were tested for ability in learning and memory using a test known as the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children (4th Edition). Also called the WISC, this test measures four areas of mental functioning including the Verbal Comprehension Index (which predicts school readiness), the Perceptual Reasoning Index (measures nonverbal and fluid reasoning), the Working Memory Index (measures a child's short term memory and ability to memorize new information) and the Processing Speed Index (which tests the child's ability to focus attention and scan, discriminate and sequentially order visual information). The Full-Scale IQ score is formed from the results of these four tests.
Results demonstrated a dose-effect response in which scores on the Working Memory Index declined by nearly 3% for each standard deviation increase in pesticide exposure.
In conclusion, the researchers stated:
This is of great concern as problems in working memory may interfere with reading comprehension, learning, and academic achievement.
Heilbrunn Center for Population and Family Health, Mailman School of Public Health,
Scientists at the Mount Sinai School of Medicine investigated pesticide exposure in 404 pregnant mothers and looked for evidence of effects upon their infant's birth weight, length, head circumference and gestational age. Mothers were primarily from East Harlem, but also from other parts of New York City.
Along with measuring for blood levels of a common organophosphate pesticide, scientists also measured the mothers' blood for an enzyme known as paraoxonase (also called PON1). PON1 is an important enzyme made by the liver that flows freely in the blood and works like a magnet to grab onto and "render harmless" organophosphate pesticides from the blood.
After comparing infant growth numbers - it was found that some mothers had infants with significantly smaller head size. This reduced head size in the child only occurred if the mother was exposed to the pesticide and also had lower than average levels of PON1. Therefore, mothers with lower levels of PON1 have pesticides remain in their blood for longer periods, thereby giving more time for the pesticides to damage their unborn child's nervous system.
In conclusion, the researchers stated:
Because small head size has been found to be predictive of subsequent cognitive ability, these data suggest that chlorpyrifos may have a detrimental effect on fetal neurodevelopment among mothers who exhibit low PON1 activity.
In another related article, it was found that infants and children have greatly reduced levels of PON1 and do not reach normal reach normal adult levels of PON1 until age 7. This innate biological factor would greatly predispose children to more harm from organophosphate pesticides. This can be seen HERE.
Department of Community & Preventive Medicine
SOURCE: International Journal of Molecular Medicine, Vol. 34(8), November 2014
The common pesticide chlorpyrifos (also called dursban or lorsban) was shown to damage the ability of body to properly control iron levels in the blood. Although banned for home and yard pest control in the United States in 2000, chlorpyrifos is still used extensively in agriculture and is routinely found as a contaminant in non-organic food sources. It also "leaks" into the indoor air due to its use as a termite barrier under the slab of homes built prior to 2000. (200 gallons of the pesticide are typically applied under the concrete slab in a 2000 square foot home).
While iron is essential for many functions in the body (i.e., liver enzymes and hemoglobin for oxygen carrying red blood cells), too much iron can cause accelerated damage to organs, including the liver and heart. In a condition known as hemochromatosis, iron levels above 1000 ng/mL typically require the individual to endure periodic "bloodletting" (removal of blood) to bring iron levels down to a normal range. While some people have mutations of cells that predispose them to the disease, it now appears that low level exposure to the pesticide chlorpyrifos can accelerate or worsen this condition by damaging the liver's ability to produce the hormone "hepcidin." Hepcidin is a critical hormone for controlling iron levels in the blood. When iron levels start to rise, the liver responds by increasing production of hepcidin. The higher hepcidin levels act as a signal and tell the small intestine to stop "re-absorbing" iron into the body, and instead, excrete iron via the feces. However, if the part of the liver that produces hepcidin is weakened (such as by pesticides), then hepcidin is no longer produced in sufficient quantities to regulate iron levels. Therefore, as pesticides can alter or weaken gene expression, it can be concluded that people with a genetic predisposition to hemochromatosis could be severely affected by even smaller levels of pesticide and chemical exposure.
HEPCIDIN REDUCED BY 50%
In conclusion the researchers stated,
We have demonstrated that chlorpyrifos exposure significantly altered the expression of central iron genes (i.e., chlorpyrifos elevates ferroportin expression in macrophages (which uptake iron for transfer to red blood cells) and represses hepcidin expression in hepatocytes (liver cells).
State Key Laboratory of Environmental Chemistry and Ecotoxicology
SOURCE: Environment International, 70:125-31, September, 2014
While a number of studies have shown pesticide exposure can result in lower child IQ, ADHD and other developmental disorders, scientists in this study wanted to determine if a mother's exposure to organophosphate pesticides during the third trimester of pregnancy would increase future social problems in the children. 404 pregnant mothers were examined for urinary levels of the organophosphate pesticide metabolite DAP during their third trimester. When children returned to the doctors for their 7-9 year visit, they were given the Social Responsiveness Scale (SRS) to look for abnormal social behaviors. While results showed there was no overall difference in SRS scores when looking at the 136 children who took the test as a group, there was a significant reduction in performance for black children and white males. Among blacks, each 10-fold increase in total DEP levels was associated with poorer social responsiveness as shown by a 5.1 point reduction in test scores.
Background: Organophosphate pesticides such as dursban (chlorpyrifos) and diazinon, have been removed from home and school use in the U.S. However, they are still used in agriculture (Lorsban, Ethion) and mosquito control (eg., malathion). Exposure can therefore come from living close to agriculture, aerial & truck mosquito spraying and also from consumption of conventional chemically grown foods (many of which are now grown in foreign countries and imported to the U.S.).
Department of Epidemiology, Gillings School of Global Public Health
SOURCE: Pediatrics, 125(6): e1270-e1277, June, 2010
Levels of pesticides commonly found in food appear to be increasing the risk of children developing attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). This was the conclusion of a study conducted by Dr. Maryse F. Bourchard, PhD, and others at the Harvard School of Public Health.
1,139 children were assessed from the National Health & Nutrition Examination Survey (2000-2004). Of these 119 met the criteria for ADHD. Results showed that children with higher urinary levels of the pesticide dimethyl alkylphosphate (DAP) were twice as likely to be diagnosed with ADHD. DAP is a metabolite and marker of recent exposure to 75% of commonly used organophosphate pesticides in food. While most organophosphate pesticides have been removed from home use, they are still used as a pesticide on food and in mosquito control (e.g. malathion - Lorsban). Therefore, people consuming conventional chemically grown food or living near agriculture would be expected to have higher urinary levels of DAP, and therefore (according to these results), would be expected to experience higher rates of ADHD in children.
According to Dr. Phil Landrigan, M.D., professor and chair of the Department of Community and Preventive Medicine at Mount Sinai School of Medicine in New York City - switching to organic food has been shown to reduce pesticides levels in the urine by 85-90%. Download the full journal article from the link above.
SOURCE: Environmental Health, Vol. 14:44, May, 2015
687 children were tested for urinary levels of the pyrethroid pesticides. Pyrethroid pesticides are typically used in truck and airplane mosquito control applications, food, and also for home and school pest control (including integrated management pest control - IPM). Children with detectable urinary levels of the pyrethroid metabolite called "3-BPA" were more than twice as likely to have hyperactive-impulsive symptoms. After that, every 10-fold increase in 3-PBA resulted in an additional 50% increase in hyperactive-impulsive behavior.
This study is of concern as pyrethroid pesticides are now commonly used as a replacement for the previously banned organophosphate pesticides. They are commonly used in school pest control - home pest control and community mosquito control applications from trucks and planes. The pesticide is also found commercially grown foods but not in organically grown foods.
SOURCE: Toxicology Letters: 2011, June 24; 23(3):245-51
Background: The home pesticide Dursban (also known
as chlorpyrifos) was an organophosphate pesticide used in homes for
decades until its ban by EPA in June 2000 (It was found to cause
birth defects and autoimmune disorders). This class of
organophosphate pesticides have now been mostly replaced with what is
known as pyrethroid pesticides for home pest control. In a study
conducted by the Anhui Medical University in China, it was found that
animals exposed to the pyrethroid pesticide fenvalerate (which
contains esfenvalerate), caused impairment in spatial learning and
memory. In addition, the pesticide increased anxiety activities in
females. The harmful effects of fenvalerate occurred when the
pesticide was exposed to animals during their human equivalent pubertal
period. This puberty period in animals (and humans) is a time in
which hormones regulate important changes in brain structure and
development. The pyrethroid pesticide fenvalerate is believed to be
an endocrine disruptor compound. Endocrine disruptor compounds are
chemicals which have the ability to mimic natural hormones in the body
(such as testosterone, progesterone and estradiol), thereby, fooling the
body into believing there is more or less of the natural hormone present.
Anhui Provincial Key Laboratory of Population
Heath & Aristogenics
SOURCE: FASEB Journal: 29(5):1960-72, May, 2015
Background: The previous studies have shown Attention Deficit Hyperactive Disorder occurs with greater frequency in children exposed to pesticides. Pesticide exposure is likely to occur from their use in schools, home & yard applications, living close to agriculture and non-organic foods. This study, using mice and post-mortem brain analysis, attempted to provide a biological explanation as to why ADHD would result from pesticide exposure.
Results: After exposing pregnant mice to pyrethroid pesticides, the offspring were observed and brain structures analyzed. According to the researchers, mice exposed to pyrethroid pesticides during development exhibit hyperactivity, impusive-like behavior, deficits in working memory and deficits in attention. Brain analysis showed the exposed mice also had elevated levels of what is called dopamine transporter and dopamine receptor levels. Dopamine is a neurotransmitter used in communication between brain cells. The picture at left is not from this study but does show a normal brain of a 20 year old young man with Learning Disabilities who died in a construction accident and reported by Dr. Albert Galaburda at Harvard Medical School. More on this and abnormal brain structures in special-ed students can be see here.
Dept. of Environmental & Occupational Med. & Environ. & Occup. Health Sciences
SOURCE: Environmental Toxicology, Volume 19(6):554-63
The backbone of your immune system is composed of cells that continuously roam your blood looking for germs, bacteria, viruses, parasites and cancer cells. If your doctor has ever drawn blood from your arm, he may have done what is called a CBC (Complete Blood Count). This will tell him the number of immune system fighting white blood cells you have. The so-called normal range is typically between 4,000 and 11,000 white blood cells per cubic millimeter of blood (a millimeter is less than 1/16th of an inch). The word "normal" is actually more of an "average" and what is applied to the middle 95% of the population. People with the lowest 2.5% and highest 2.5% are not included. As far as the numbers go, it is better to be in the upper half of this range thereby giving you more immune cells to fight bacteria, viruses and cancer. People at the very low end of "normal" are typically predisposed to higher rates of infection. Approximately 5% of your white blood cells (cells of the immune system) are called natural killer cells. These cells perform a critical role in destroying early stages of viral infections and cancer. In a study done at the Department of Chemistry, Tennessee State University, researchers found that very low levels of carbamate pesticides used in agriculture could weaken the ability of natural killer cells to destroy viruses or cancer cells. To quote the scientists,
SOURCE: Journal of Clinical Endocrinology Metabolism
The pesticide DDT was found to increase the risk of breast cancer in women whose mothers were exposed to DDT during pregnancy. While other studies have looked at breast cancer risk as related to DDT levels in the person with breast cancer, this study is the first to look at DDT levels of mothers and their child's subsequent diagnosis of breast cancer.
Chem-Tox Comment: DDT was a pesticide used during the 1960's until its ban in the U.S. in 1972. Unfortunately, DDT can still be manufactured in the U.S., and is sold to other countries. Countries in South America routinely use DDT on food crops and then export these crops back into the U.S. Also, the pesticide Kelthane (dicofol), contains DDT as a contaminant at levels up to 10% and is routinely used today in citrus agriculture in Florida and California. Therefore, exposure comes not only from chemically grown foods but also from living close to agriculture in Florida and California.
SOURCE: Breast Cancer Research and Treatment, Volume 90:55-64, 2005
One in eight women in the United States
will develop breast cancer according to the latest statistics.
Breast cancer rates in the U.S. are 3-7 times higher than those in Asia.
This 2005 study conducted at the US Army Institute of Surgical Research
and Texas Tech University Health Science Center in Lubbock Texas found
that cancerous human breast tissue contained the chemical heptachlor
epoxide (found in the common home pesticide chlordane) at levels 4 times
higher than non-cancerous breast tissue. Chlordane was the primary
termite prevention pesticide used in over 30 million U.S. homes between
the mid 1950's and 1988. An estimated 50 million U.S. residents are
currently exposed to the volatization of this chemical from previously
treated pre-1989 homes on a daily basis. (For more information on
chlordane go to
Birth Defects Higher in Families Living near Farming Areas
SOURCE: Environmental Health Perspectives
Babies born to families living near wheat growing agricultural areas using chemical pesticides have been found to have a 65% greater risk of having birth defects related to the circulatory and respiratory system. The pesticide category believed to be the culprit is known as chlorophenoxy herbicides that contain the chemical 2,4-D. Chlorophenoxy herbicides are used to kill a variety of weeds and are also commonly used by city and county maintenance departments for grass and weed control along roads, canals etc. When looking at musculoskeletal anomalies for both sexes in the high-wheat growing counties, there was a 50% increased risk of these types of defects. Infant deaths for male babies (from congenital anomalies related to the birth defects) was over 2.5 times higher than normal. Scientists also found that infants conceived from April-June (the time of primary pesticide application) had a 75% increased risk of being diagnosed with birth defects - compared to birth defect rates for conception during other times of the year.
In conclusion, the scientists stated - "These results are especially of concern because of widespread use of chlorophenoxy herbicides."
Dina M. Schreinemachers
Immune System Weakening and Frog Mutations
from Pesticides used in Mosquito Control - Lawns - and Agriculture
SOURCE: Article below appeared in the San
Raising new questions about the environmental risks of some widely used farm chemicals, scientists are reporting today the first evidence linking agricultural runoff to grotesque hind-limb deformities in frogs. Researchers said frogs appear to be made more vulnerable to a common parasite when exposed to the pesticides atrazine and malathion. The parasite, a burrowing trematode worm, tends to infect the hindquarters of developing tadpoles. Atrazine is part of a family of chemicals that rank among the world's most widely used weed killers. Malathion is commonly applied to control mosquitoes and other insects, and pharmaceutical grades are approved for killing head lice. Both products are controversial but considered safe for commercial use in the United States.
At last count, wild frogs with missing or extra hind limbs have been observed in at least 43 states and five Canadian provinces. Earlier studies clearly implicated the trematode parasite but left open the question of what might be causing the apparent increase in the problem.
The latest study, by ecologist Joseph Kiesecker at Pennsylvania State University and edited by UC Berkeley amphibian specialist David Wake, tries to fit in the key remaining puzzle piece. The study appears in the early edition of this week's Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.
Kiesecker said his observations of the common wood frog Rana sylvatica in the wild, followed by controlled studies in his laboratory, produced "compelling" evidence that pesticides can weaken the immune system of exposed amphibians -- even at very low concentrations -- making the frogs more vulnerable to parasites.
The field studies showed "considerably higher rates of limb deformities where there was pesticide exposure," Kiesecker said in an interview. "Then the lab experiments helped support the mechanism for what we saw in the field."
He also looked at another pesticide, a synthetic chemical called esfenvalerate, but did not find the same links to growth anomalies as seen with malathion and atrazine.
For the latter two chemicals, significant effects were seen even at concentrations considered safe for drinking water by the Environmental Protection Agency.
Even these very low levels of exposure could produce "dramatic effects on the immune response" of the animals. And that, in turn, led to significantly more growth defects.
Kiesecker stopped short of endorsing any effort to further restrict use of atrazine and malathion. But he said his results underscored the importance of studying toxic chemical effects in a context approaching the complexity found in natural ecosystems.
In this case, he explained, the two farm chemicals "disturbed host-pathogen interactions" with sometimes devastating effects. But all that would be missed in traditional studies examining only the chemicals and the frogs in isolation.
Some other scientists, backed by the farm-chemical industry, challenged Kiesecker's results. Although they said the new study was intriguing, they suggested the details couldn't be trusted until corroborated independently.
Original Journal Article Author Information:
SOURCE: Annals of Oncology, 5(1):S19-S24, 1994
Below is the abstract from this article:
The epidemiology of Non-Hodgkin's lymphoma (NHL) was reviewed. In the United States, the annual incidence of NHL rose from 5.9 per 100,000 people in 1950 to 9.3 per 100,000 in 1975, to 13.7 in 1989. The elderly showed the greatest increase. Most of the recent increase was not attributable to acquired immune deficiency syndrome. Mortality rates due to NHL were increasing at almost 2% per year. The largest proportional increases occurred in the brain and other areas of the nervous system. Occupational studies have indicated that persons with certain jobs have an increased risk, including farmers, applicators of pesticides, grain millers, wood and forestry workers, chemists, cosmetologists, machinists, printers, and those working in the petroleum, rubber, plastics, and synthetics industries. A three to nine fold increased risk of developing NHL was noted for patients receiving treatment with alkylating agents or radiotherapy. The most extensive data related to pesticides and the occurrence of NHL suggest that exposure to phenoxy herbicides, particularly 2,4-D (94757), is linked to NHL. Flour millers exposed to fungicides and fumigant pesticides had over a four fold increased risk of NHL; long term follow-up indicated this risk increased to nine fold. An etiologic link between exposure to various solvents and NHL has been defined by recent studies including benzene (71432), styrene (100425), 1,3-butadiene (106990), trichlorethylene (79016), perchloroethylene (127184), creosote (8021394), lead-arsenate (10102484), formaldehyde (50000), paint thinners, and oils and greases. Recent findings also indicated an increased risk of NHL in those exposed to dusts and particles, hair dyes, and cigarette smoke. An association was noted between NHL and Helicobacter-pylori infection. Nitrate contamination of groundwater also may be linked to increased incidences of NHL.
SOURCE: Environmental News Service, May 10, 2002
DURHAM, North Carolina, May 10, 2002 (ENS) - A common ingredient in mosquito and tick repellents may be linked to some neurological problems, a new study suggests.
A Duke University Medical Center pharmacologist is recommending caution when using the insecticide DEET, after his animal studies last year found the chemical causes diffuse brain cell death and behavioral changes in rats after frequent and prolonged use
Mohamed Abou-Donia, PhD has called for further government testing of the chemical's safety in short term and occasional use, particularly in view of Health Canada's recent decision to ban products with more than 30 percent of the chemical.
Every year, about one-third of the U.S. population uses insect repellents containing DEET, available in more than 230 products with concentrations up to 100 percent. While the chemical's risks to humans are still being intensely debated, Abou-Donia says his 30 years of research on pesticides' brain effects indicate the need for caution among the general public.
His numerous studies in rats, two of them published last year, demonstrate that frequent and prolonged applications of DEET cause neurons to die in regions of the brain that control muscle movement, learning, memory and concentration. Rats treated with an average human dose of DEET - 40 milligrams per kilogram body weight - performed far worse than control rats when challenged with physical tasks requiring muscle control, strength and coordination.
Such effects are consistent with physical symptoms in humans reported in the medical literature, such as those experienced by some Gulf War veterans, said Abou-Donia.
"If used sparingly, infrequently and by itself, DEET may not have negative effects - the literature here isn't clear," Abou-Donia said. "But frequent and heavy use of DEET, especially in combination with other chemicals or medications, could cause brain deficits in vulnerable populations."
Children are at particular risk for subtle brain changes caused by chemicals in the environment, because their skin more readily absorbs them, and chemicals may affect their developing nervous systems, said Abou-Donia.
Preparations like insecticide based lice killing shampoos and insect repellents are assumed to be safe because severe consequences are rare in the medical literature. Yet subtle symptoms, such as muscle weakness, fatigue or memory lapses, might be attributed to other causes in error, Abou-Donia said.
"The take home message is to be safe and cautious when using insecticides," said Abou-Donia. "Never use insect repellents on infants, and be wary of using them on children in general. Never combine insecticides with each other or use them with other medications. Even so simple a drug as an antihistamine could interact with DEET to cause toxic side effects. Don't spray your yard for bugs and then take medications. Until we have more data on potential interactions in humans, safe is better than sorry."
SOURCE: Epidemiology, 12(2), March 2001
Approximately 19,000 fetal deaths (stillborn) occur each year in the United States. The causes of these deaths remains unclear. Researchers from the University of North Carolina and the National Cancer Institute (NCI) worked together in this study of over 600 children to determine what part local pesticide use plays in increasing the risk of having a late fetal death after 5 months of pregnancy. Using maps and records of pesticide use, the researchers divided mothers into categories according to how close they lived to pesticide applications. If they lived within 1 mile of an agricultural pesticide application that occurred between weeks 3-8 of gestation they were considered as "exposed." Weeks 3-8 during pregnancy were selected since this is the critical period in which formation of organs and limbs are occurring. Results of this study showed there was approximately 2-fold greater risk of having a stillbirth if the mother lived within 1 mile from an agricultural area which used organophosphate - pyrethroid - carbamate - or chlorinated pesticides. Primary defects which contributed to the death of the child were urinary system and multiple congenital anomalies.CHEM-TOX COMMENT: This research is particularly important because it is the first to determine risk if limiting exposure to the 3-8 week gestational period, thereby demonstrating true risk to pregnant mothers in schools, homes, offices and neighborhood mosquito control projects. Other studies would have diluted results since they have been done on a trimester basis. Also of great concern is the increased risk stated here for having a stillborn child after exposure to pyrethroid pesticides. Pyrethroid based pesticides are the main pesticide used for mosquito control truck applications and should therefore, raise concerns regarding exposure to pregnant women living in mosquito spray areas.
This is not the first study to find a link between pesticides and fetal defects - another study reported in Epidemiology, 10:60, 1999, found pregnant mothers had a 70% increased risk for congenital defects if home pesticides were used or if living within a quarter-mile of an agricultural crop during the month before conception and the first trimester of pregnancy.
Erin M. Bell
SOURCE: Epidemiology: 12(1):20-26, January, 2001
One of the largest studies to date has found that pesticide use around the home can more than double the chance of a child developing neuroblastoma.
Neuroblastoma accounts for approximately 10% of all childhood tumors. There are 550 new cases in the United States each year, with an annual incidence rate of 9.2 cases per million children under 15 years of age. This works out to approximately 1 per 100,000 children under age 15 on a national level. (These rates were reported in the book "Principles and Practice of Pediatric Oncology, Lippincott-Raven, 1997). It is a very serious cancer as approximately 60% of children over age 1 who develop neuroblastoma do not live 3 years even when receiving treatments of radiation and chemotherapy. Children under age 1 have a more positive prognosis. As statistics show that neuroblastoma rates have increased over the past 50 years, it is reasonable to assume environmental factors may be involved.
One of the largest collaborative efforts among 7 Universities and medical facilities worked together to determine what extent pesticide use in the home could increase child neuroblastoma rates. 390 neuroblastoma children and 460 non-cancer controls were included in the study. Investigators questioned both parents regarding use of pesticides in and around the home.Results showed that using pesticides in and around the home resulted in a 60% increased likelihood of children developing the disease (Odds Ratio=1.6). Looking at pesticide use for the lawn and garden only resulted in an increased risk of 120% (Odds Ratio=2.2) when the mother had applied pesticides in the yard and 50% higher (Odds Ratio=1.5) when the father had applied pesticides in the yard. (Chem-Tox Note: Outdoor pesticides are much different from indoor pesticides as they include fungicides and herbicides some of which have been reported to contain dioxin.
Julie L. Daniels, Andrew F. Olshan, Kay Teschke, Irva
Hertz-Picciotto, Dave A. Savitz, Julie Blatt, Melissa L. Bondy, Joseph P.
Neglia, Brad H. Pollock, Susan L. Cohn, A. Thomas Look, Robert C. Seeger,
Robert P. Castleberry
SOURCE: Epidemiology, March 2001
Living close to areas where agricultural pesticides are applied may increase the risk of fetal death from birth defects according to research conducted at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. The study, which involved almost 700 women in 10 California counties, showed an increased risk of death among developing babies. Mothers who lived near crops where certain pesticides were sprayed faced a 40 to 120 percent increase in risk of miscarriage due to birth defects.
"Our study showed a consistent pattern with respect to timing of exposure," said Dr. Erin Bell, who earned her doctorate with the research at the University of North Carolina (UNC) School of Public Health. "The largest risks for fetal death due to birth defects were from pesticide exposure during the third week to the eighth week of pregnancy."
"The risks appeared to be strongest among pregnant women who lived in the same square mile where pesticides were used," she said.
"This is the first study to our knowledge of pesticides and pregnancy in which exposures were in close proximity to the subjects and the verification of pesticide use was objective, not relying on people's memories of what they might have been exposed to," Hertz-Picciotto said.
About 19,000 fetal deaths occur in the United States each year, and the causes remain a significant public health problem, Bell said. Among known risk factors are smoking, advanced age among pregnant women and previous history of fetal deaths.
Erin Bell (Ph.D.)
SOURCE: CANCER:89:11, 2000
Children who have been exposed to household insecticides and professional extermination methods within the home are three to seven times more likely to develop non-Hodgkin lymphoma (NHL) compared with children who have not been exposed to pesticides. These are the results of a study published in the December 1, 2000 issue of the journal CANCER, an international publication of the American Cancer Society. The study indicated that a child's risk of developing NHL was similar for both maternal exposure to pesticides during pregnancy (in utero) and direct (postnatal) exposure to pesticides. Significant variations in risk were associated with various NHL morphologies. For instance, the use of household insecticides increased the risk of lymphoblastic lymphoma by 12.5 times. The term "pesticides" refers to a group of chemicals that have in common their ability to kill insects, plants, mammals (particularly rodents), or fungi.
"A limited number of these compounds may be capable of inducing lymphoma, particularly when used around the home," comments chief researcher Jonathan D. Buckley, M.B.B.S., Ph.D., from the Department of Preventative Medicine at the University of Southern California in Los Angeles. Lymphoma, the third most common childhood malignancy, occurs at a rate of 21.7 per million in children age < 15 years. Approximately 60% of these cases are NHL. In the current study, the Children's Cancer Group evaluated the correlation between home pesticide use or occupational exposure to pesticides and the incidence of NHL in a pediatric study sample.
The study included children and adolescents age < 20 years who were diagnosed with NHL between February 1986 and June 1990. Tumors were classified according to cell type (predominantly B-cell or T-cell). Telephone interviews with the participants' mothers included questions regarding occupational and home exposure to pesticides around the time of pregnancy and direct exposure of the child to pesticides. From a total of 268 NHL pediatric cases examined, 49 of the patients had lymphomatous leukemia, whereas the other 218 patients were diagnosed with various NHL morphologies, including lymphoblastic subtype (38%), Burkitt lymphoma (28%), undifferentiated (non-Burkitt) lymphoma (12%), and large-cell NHL (19%). Frequency of household insecticide use by the mothers around the time of the pregnancy (in utero) was associated with a 2.62-fold greater risk of NHL for limited applications (1-2 days per week), compared with a 7.33-fold greater risk for regular use (on most days). Professional home extermination was related to a 3-fold greater risk for developing NHL. Direct (postnatal) exposure of the child to pesticides was associated with a 2.4-fold greater risk, whereas occupational exposure and the use of pesticide sprays in the garden demonstrated an increased risk, although not statistically significant. When the researchers focused their analysis on the association between different types of pesticide exposure and the development of different NHL morphologies, they observed the risk for developing lymphoblastic lymphoma was 12.5 times greater after a child's exposure to household insecticide use. The risk of developing Burkitt lymphoma was observed to be 9.6 times greater after occupational exposure to pesticides. The risk for developing large cell lymphoma or Burkitt lymphoma was 6.7 and 8.0 times higher, respectively, after professional insect extermination. The authors note that the most statistically significant correlation between exposure to pesticides and the risk for developing NHL were observed for those children who were directly exposed to pesticides. The risk for developing lymphoblastic subtype lymphoma and large cell non-Hodgkin's lymphoma was 10.9 times and 6.5 times greater, respectively, for these children compared with children who have not been exposed to pesticides. The researchers also noted a 7.1 times greater risk for Burkitt lymphoma among these children. Overall elevations in the risk associated with pesticide exposure were present for both the younger (age < 6 years) and older (age > 6 years) study participants.
Jonathan D Buckley, M.B.B.S. Ph.D.
Brain Development Harm During Pregnancy
SOURCE: Toxicology and Applied Pharmacology 134, 53-62, 1995
Chem-Tox Comment: During the past 30 years there has been an alarming rise in the rates of children exhibiting various forms of subtle brain damage including - learning disabilities - autism - and attention deficit disorder. Understanding that the human brain begins growing at over 4,000 cells per second beginning in the 4th week of pregnancy demonstrates the importance of avoiding petroleum based compounds in order to attain maximum brain growth quality. The following research was conducted at the Department of Pharmacology, Duke University Medical Center, Durham, North Carolina. The first paragraph below is taken from the abstract of the original research.
In summary the researchers stated,
SOURCE: Organic Gardening, July, 2000
Thousands and thousands of acres in the United States are being sprayed annually with nearly 50 million pounds of Roundup, a broad-spectrum herbicide designed to kill any plant it hits, unless the plant has been genetically altered to tolerate the chemical. Roundup has accounted for half of Monsanto's corporate profits in recent years. Now the company has expanded its Roundup market by genetically engineering "Roundup Ready" soybeans, corn, and other crops. Monsanto's advertising campaigns have convinced many people that Roundup is safe, but the facts simply do not support that conclusion. Independent scientific studies have shown that Roundup is toxic to earthworms, beneficial insects, birds and mammals. Plus it destroys the vegetation on which they depend for food and shelter. And although Monsanto claims that Roundup breaks down into harmless substances, it has been found to be extremely persistent, with residue absorbed by subsequent crops over a year after application. Roundup show adverse effects in all standard categories of toxicological testing, including medium-term toxicity, long-term toxicity, genetic damage, effects on reproduction, and carcinogenicity. Here is some of the research that demonstrates the ways that Roundup's active ingredient, glyphosate, adversely affects plants and animals:
In a study conducted by T.B. Moorman and colleagues at the USDA Southern Weed Science Laboratory in Stoneville, Mississippi, glyphosate reduced soybeans' and clover's ability to fix nitrogen. A study conducted by G.S. Johal and J.E. Rahe of the Center for Pest Management at Simon Frase University in Burnaby, British Columbia, found that glyphosate made bean plants more susceptible to disease. At Dalhousie University in Halifax, Nova Scotia, D. Estok and colleagues found that glyphosate reduces the growth of beneficial soil-dwelling mycorrhizal fungi. Moving up to mammals, sperm production in rabbits was diminished by 50 percent when they were exposed to glyphosate, in research conducted by M.I. Youset and colleagues at the University of Alexandria in Egypt and the University of Tromso in Norway. Brand-new evidence suggests that Roundup may cause cancer. The study, published in Environmental and Molecular Mutagenesis (vol. 31 pp. 55-59, 1998), found that an unidentified chemical in Roundup caused genetic damage in the livers and kidneys of mice exposed to the herbicide. The researchers believe additional experiments are needed to determine which chemical in the Roundup mixture is causing the damage. They point out that this will be very difficult because "the precise composition of the mixture...is not available due to protection by patent regulation." In other words, Monsanto doesn't have to reveal to the public exactly what chemicals are in Roundup. In California, where pesticide-related illness must be reported, Roundup's active ingredient (glyphosate) was the third most commonly reported cause of pesticide illness among agricultural workers, and the most common cause of pesticide illness in landscape workers. According to two New Zealand toxicologists, the symptoms experienced by workers exposed to Roundup included eye and skin irritation, headaches, nausea and heart palpitations.
SOURCE: Biochem Soc Trans, 28(2):81-4, 2000
BACKGROUND: In the last two decades reports from different countries emerged associating pesticide and herbicide use with Parkinson's disease (PD). California growers use approximately 250 million pounds of pesticides annually, about a quarter of all pesticides used in the US. METHODS: We employed a proportional odds mortality design to compare all cases of PD recorded as underlying (1984-1994) or associated causes (1984-1993) of death occurring in California with all deaths from ischaemic heart disease (ICD-9 410-414) during the same period. Based on pesticide use report data we classified California counties into several pesticide use categories. Agricultural census data allowed us to create measures of percentage of land per county treated with pesticides. Employing logistic regression models we estimated the effect of pesticide use controlling for age, gender, race, birthplace, year of deaths, and education. RESULTS: Mortality from PD as the underlying cause of death was higher in agricultural pesticide-use counties than in non-use counties. A dose response was observed for insecticide use per county land treated when using 1982 agricultural census data, but not for amounts of restricted pesticides used or length of residency in a country prior to death. CONCLUSIONS: Our data show an increased PD mortality in California counties using agricultural pesticides. Unless all of our measures of county pesticide use are surrogates for other risk factors more prevalent in pesticide use counties, it seems important to target this prevalent exposure in rural California in future studies that use improved case finding mechanisms and collect pesticide exposure data for individuals.
Ritz B, Yu F
Parkinson's Disease Linked to Pesticide Combination
SOURCE: Journal of Neuroscience, December 15, 2000
A combination of two commonly used agricultural pesticides,
when injected into mice, causes the same pattern of brain damage seen in
Parkinson's disease, researchers said on Thursday.
Mice injected with one or the other alone showed no ill effects, but when the combination was given they showed clear patterns of brain damage.
The mice moved around much less than normal and had lower
levels of an enzyme known as tyrosine hydroxylase that is used as a measure
of the health of the dopamine system.
University of Rochester School of Medicine
SOURCE: Occupational Environmental Medicine, 56(1):14-21, 1999
OBJECTIVES: Although the primary hazard to humans associated with
pesticide exposure is acute poisoning, there has been considerable concern
surrounding the possibility of cancer and other chronic health effects in
humans. Given the huge volume of pesticides now used throughout the world, as
well as environmental and food residue contamination leading to chronic low level
exposure, the study of possible chronic human health effects is important.
Fleming LE, Bean JA, Rudolph M, Hamilton K
SOURCE: American Journal of Public Health, 86(9): 1289-96, 1996
Living closer than 2600 feet to an agriculture area has been found to increase the risk
for developing brain cancer. This 1996 research project studied cancer
rates among over 600 people. Brain cancer overall showed a twofold increase
risk for people living within the 2600 foot distance. An astounding 6.7 fold
increased risk was found for the brain cancer type known as astrocytes for people living
within 2600 feet from an agriculture area. For more information on brain cancer and
Drs. A. Aschengrau, D. Ozonoff, P.Coogan, R. Vezina, T. Heeren
SOURCE: American Journal of Industrial Medicine, 29(5):501-506, 1996
Working as a Golf Course Superintendent has been found to significantly increase the risk of dying of four cancer types including - brain cancer, lymphoma (non-Hodgkin's lymphoma, NHL), prostate and large intestine cancer. A study was conducted of 686 deceased members of the Golf Course Superintendents Association of America from all U.S. states who died between 1970 and 1992. Brain cancer rates for the Superintendents was found to occur at over twice the national average, while non-Hodgkin's lymphoma also occurred at over twice the national average. Prostate cancer occurred at nearly 3 times the national average and large intestinal cancer occurred at 1.75 times the national average. The researchers stated that a similar pattern of elevated NHL, brain and prostate cancer mortality along with excess deaths from diseases of the nervous system has been noted previously among other occupational groups exposed to pesticides.
Drs. Kross, B.C., Burneister, L.F., Ogilvie, L.K., Fuortes, L.J.,
SOURCE: Journal of the National Cancer Institute, July 1987
Children who live in homes where indoor or outdoor pesticides are used face a far greater chance of developing leukemia (leukemia is a cancer of the blood). The study, published in July's 1987 issue of the Journal of the National Cancer Institute, studied 123 Los Angeles children with leukemia and 123 children without the malignancy. The results showed the children living in the pesticide treated homes had nearly a 4 times greater risk of developing the disease. If the children lived in homes where pesticides were used in the garden as well, the risk of developing leukemia was 6.5 times greater. All of the children in the study were 10 years of age or younger.
Dr. John Peters
In research to determine the amount of indoor air contamination following routine
indoor application of pesticides, it was found the levels of the pesticide Dursban drop to
only one-sixth of its original 1 hour level four days after application. The research was
conducted by Dow Chemical (1). The no-odor pesticide Ficam was reported to have an air
half-life of approximately 10 days (2). Of significant concern is the discovery that
the pesticide soil drench procedure (a procedure in which approximately 200
gallons of pesticides are saturated into the soil just prior to the pouring of the
concrete foundation in new home construction) is finding its way into the indoor
air for literally years and years after application. It was originally thought that
the concrete foundation provided a solid barrier to the poison. However, air testing
technology has shown this is not the case (3). Just as radon finds its way into a home,
entering from the soil, the pesticide vapors do also moving from the high pressure
underneath the home and into the lower pressure inside the home. It enters through
cracks in foundation, around plumbing fixtures, etc. This provides strong evidence
that this procedure should be eliminated immediately and alternative methods be used.
Alternative methods include using only concrete and metal framing - using
non-volatile Sodium Borate treatment on the wood framing before installing drywall - using
pesticide spikes embedded in the soil around the perimeter of the home (this is still a
chemical pesticide and therefore is not a first option but may satisfy the Lenders).
Other research at University of Florida has shown that larger "sand" granules do
not allow termites to build their nests. Unfortunately, the pesticide industry has
worked its way solidly into new home construction practices and therefore takes a little
effort on the homeowner's part to stop the pesticide soil drench procedure - (It can be
done however, as it is not a law, but rather a recommended procedure in the Southern
Building Code and one the lenders like to see done. Go talk to your lender personally and
tell them about the alternatives and threaten to take your business somewhere
else.). The bottom line is these chemicals do enter the home and they do accelerate
the onset of health problems (as seen in the research on this page) including aging of the
immune and nervous system and therefore should not be applied underneath the home.
SOURCE: Archives of Environmental Health, 48(2):89-93, March/April 1993
The pesticide Dursban (also called chlorpyrifos), commonly used in indoor and lawn pest control, is now showing evidence of causing immune system disorders in people. In a study by the Department of Health Science at California State University, 12 individuals, which included a teacher, six housewives, a retail owner, a musician and an engineer, were studied for 1 to 4.5 years after they became ill when their home or place of employment was treated with the pesticide. The researchers were investigating for any abnormalities in immune system function. Immediately following each patient's exposure to the pesticide, common complaints included an initial flu-like illness followed by chronic complaints of fatigue, headaches, dizziness, loss of memory, upper and lower respiratory symptoms, joint and muscle pain and gastrointestinal disturbances. The subjects were found to have an elevated number of CD26 cells and a higher rate of autoimmune problems, compared with two other control groups. (Autoimmune disorders occur when the person's own immune system mistakenly makes antibodies which attack their own body.) Autoantibodies were found toward smooth muscle, parietal cell, brush border, thyroid gland, myelin, and ANA. 83% of the pesticide exposed people were found to have autoantibodies in their blood, in comparison to only 15% for non-exposed control group. 50% of the pesticide exposed people were also found to have two or more autoantibodies in comparison to only 4% for the non-exposed group.
In conclusion the researchers stated,
Jack D. Thrasher Ph.D., Roberta Madison, Alan Broughton
SOURCE: American Journal of Public Health, 80(6):689-693, 1990
Applying common flea pesticide treatments to carpets results in illegally high air pesticide levels in homes which lasts for over 24 hours after application. This was the conclusion of research conducted by Dr. Richard A. Fenske, Assistant Professor at Rutgers University. Tests were conducted by applying the common pesticide Chlorpyrifos (Dursban) for flea treatment by a licensed Pest Control Applicator to three rooms of an unoccupied apartment in New Jersey in June, 1987. Air sampling equipment was installed above the floor at the levels expected for an adult sitting in a chair and that of an infant. After application, samples were taken at 30 minutes, 1 hour, 1.5 hours, 3 hours, 5 hours, 7 hours and 24 hours. Results showed that at 5 hours post application, indoor air levels of the pesticide was nearly twice above the legal limit in homes with ventilation (an open window) and over 6 times above the legal limit at 7 hours where windows were closed. Levels at the infant breathing zone were nearly 10 times above the legal limit at 7 hours and over 3 times the legal limit even after 24 hours. These results show it is incorrect when Pesticide Applicators state it is safe to return home several hours after application. In fact, levels at 7 hours were 3-5 times higher than the 1.5 hour level. In conclusion the researchers stated,
Richard A. Fenske, Ph.D., MPH
|Pesticide Inhalation Associated with Brain and Lung Cancer
SOURCE: Journal of the National Cancer Institute, 71(1), July 1983
A study of 3,827 Florida pesticide applicators employed for 20 or more years found they had nearly 3 times the risk for developing lung cancer. The same study also showed the pesticide applicators had twice the risk for brain cancer. There was not any increased cancer risk when applicators were studied for only 5 years implying it takes over 5 years to accumulate enough damage to the genetic structure to develop the cancers.
SOURCE: 3 references listed below
The pesticide MCPA, used as an ingredient is some lawn pesticides, has been found to damage a part of the brain known as the blood brain barrier (1). The blood brain barrier is the brain's primary defense system which works to keep toxic substances out of the brain cells and is literally protecting all of us from developing immediate neurological illness. The blood brain barrier has been found to be defective more often in patients with Alzheimers and some psychiatric disorders (2). In fact, the lack of functioning of the blood brain barrier in the human infant has been reported on many occasions as being the reason why an infant is being found to develop brain damage after exposure to common chemicals while an adult with a mature blood brain barrier does not. Unfortunately, EPA neurotoxicologist Dr. Bill Sette stated EPA does not yet require chemical companies to test any of their pesticides for causing blood brain barrier damage. Another study of 56 men exposed to organophosphate pesticides detected memory problems and difficulty in maintaining alertness and focusing attention (3). Each of these studies will be listed here in greater detail shortly as our web site completes development. As the understanding of blood brain barrier function is of critical importance to understanding why one individual can receive more damage to his/her nervous system than someone else, we will also include a blood brain barrier site with the address www.chem-tox.com/bbb.
1. Toxicology and Applied Pharmacology, 65:23, 1982
SOURCE: Bulletin of Environmental Contamination Toxicology, 54:363-369, 1995
Of the many different types of pesticides (which include insecticides, herbicides and fungicides), it was found that the common fungicide "cyproconazole" caused serious defects when administered to test animals. This chemical is reported to be widely used in agriculture and is a member of the family of fungicides known as triazole fungicides. It's closely related family members include the fungicides triadimefon, triadimenol, bitertanol, flusilazole, 1,2,4-triazole, and propiconazole. Each of these pesticides were reported in this article as being capable of causing birth defects in test animals when administered at doses as low as 30 mg/kg. These chemicals are far more toxic than even standard insecticides. The "No Observable Effect Level" (which means the maximum amount of the chemical that test animals can be exposed to without seeing any adverse effects) is reported to be only 2 mg/kg for flusilazole.
The study on the effects of cyproconazole (lets call it CPZ for simplicity) was headed by Dr. K. Machera, at the Laboratory of Pesticide Toxicology in Athens, Greece. Dr. Machera exposed 10 pregnant animals to different levels of CPZ ranging from 20-75 mg/kg from the 6th to the 16th day of pregnancy. On the 21st day of pregnancy the animals were sacrificed and the number of implantations, resorption sites and live and dead fetuses were recorded. The fetuses were weighed and examined for abnormalities.
Results showed the number of resorptions (similar to an early miscarriage) was over 8 times greater for those exposed to the 50 and 75 mg/kg doses. The fetal length was significantly smaller in doses from 50 mg/kg up. The fetal body weight was significantly less even at the lowest dose of 20 mg/kg.
Cleft Pallat did not occur in any of the 100 offspring not exposed to CPZ. However, cleft pallat did occur in 2% of posed to 20 mg/kg of CPZ, 20% of posed to 50 mg/kg of CPZ and 91% of posed to the highest 100 mg/kg dose.
The same trend was also seen with hydrocephalus - 0% for the animals not exposed to CPZ, 6% for posed to 20 mg/kg, 19% for posed to 50 mg/kg, 32% for posed to 75 mg/kg and 100% for the 12 posed to the 100 mg/kg level.
These studies demonstrate the definite potential for pesticides in the triazole family to increase the risk of lower birthweight, lower body length, as well as strongly increasing the risk of cleft palate and hydrocephalus. With results such as this in test animals, it would certainly be worthwhile to investigate the incidence of these conditions among people living in close proximity to agricultural areas. Dr. Machera did not state if these chemicals were used on residential lawns as an anti-fungal agent. Keep in mind that these studies were looking for physical defects and were not looking for neurological defects in offspring (which typically occur at much lower dosages).
Dr. K. Machera
The lawn pesticides, mancozeb and chlorothalonil (used by commercial lawn spray companies as fungicides), have been classified by EPA as "probable" cancer causing chemicals in humans as they have been found to cause cancer in animals (1). Mancozeb has also been found to react with sunlight to form a new compound EPA categorizes as a "known" human carcinogen (1). The common lawn pesticide 2,4-D has been shown to increase the risk of lymphatic cancer in farmers six times the normal rate according to a National Cancer Institute report (2).
SOURCE: Teratogenesis, Carcinogenesis, and Mutagenesis 7:527-540, 1987
There is approximately a 75% chance you are breathing the pesticide chlordane every minute you are inside your home if your home was built before March of 1988. Other studies have shown there is a 6-7% chance you are breathing dangerously high levels of the pesticide which are above the guidelines set by the National Academy of Sciences. This problem is occurring because over 30 million homes were treated with the chemical prior to its being banned by the EPA in March of 1988. The air chlordane studies were conducted by the U.S. Air Force and the New Jersey Department of Environmental Regulation. Over 1000 homes and apartments were tested in different parts of the nation. The researchers stated they expect the figures to remain the same throughout the country because of standardized application practices by the pest control companies. If you would like more detailed information on the chlordane problem and the health effects suspected for the millions of Americans living in chlordane treated homes - visit the chlordane web site by clicking this link.
Samuel S. Epstein and David Ozonoff
SOURCE: Neurotoxicology and Teratology, Vol. 11:45-50, 1989
Groups of test animals exposed to different pesticides used in agriculture and lawn care showed over 50% more activity following a single exposure to the chemical. One of the main goals of this experiment, conducted by Dr. J. A. Mitchell and colleagues at the University of Michigan, was to investigate activity behavioral changes in test animals (male Swiss mice) following a single exposure to one of 4 different dosages of weed killers and fungicides. The chemicals used included Lasso (containing alachlor), Basalin (containing fluchloralin), Premiere (containing dinoseb) and the fungicide Maneb-80 (80% Maneb).. Test dosages ranged from a very low 0.4 mg/kg to 4 mg/kg to 40 mg/kg. Even the largest dose was still below the LD-50 for the animals (the amount needed to kill 50% of the test animals). According to the researchers, the herbicides and fungicides have received few reports investigating their toxicity while their yearly growth and production have grown far more than the insecticides.
The detection of hyperactivity was measured by placing the test animals in steel cages that were equipped with electronic motion detectors which used infrared beams to count specific movements by the animals. After the single chemical exposure, activity was measured for a 4 hour period. Results showed the weed killer "Lasso" did not show any effects at the very low .4 mg/kg level but did show over a 65% increase in activity at the low 4 mg/kg and a 75% increase at the higher 40 mg/kg level. The weed killer Dinoseb also showed no activity increases at the lowest .4 mg/kg dose but did show a 15% increase at the 4 mg/kg level and a 54% increase at the larger 40 mg/kg level. Other researchers have reported that activity provides a sensitive measure for evaluating the behavioral effects of the pyrethroid pesticide, deltamethrin, at doses that did not cause the characteristic neurotoxicological syndrome (6).
In conclusion the researchers stated,
Dr. J. A. Mitchell, S. F. Long
SOURCE: Environmental Health Perspectives, 103:690-694, 1995
In 1987, over 250 adults and children were exposed to the pesticide chlordane when the wooden building surfaces and soil around their apartment complex was sprayed. Their exposure came from the vapors that entered into their home for the years after the chemical's application. Levels inside the homes were reported above 0.5 mcg/m3.
In June-September 1994, 216 adult occupants or former residents of the apartment complex were examined by researchers at the University of Southern California School of Medicine in Los Angeles. The 109 women and 97 men were given a battery of neurological tests to determine if the low levels of chlordane in their apartments was causing any harmful effects. The tests given are considered sensitive indicators of neurotoxicity. To determine if chlordane was in fact causing neurological problems, the test scores of the chlordane exposed adults were compared to the test scores of 94 women and 68 men from Houston, known not to have been exposed to chlordane.
Results of the testing showed many negative effects upon mental function from the low levels of air chlordane. Not only were test scores lower for reaction time, balance, and memory, but also worse scores were observed in the test checking for attention deficits (digit symbol) and all tests of mood scores including tension, depression, anger, vigor and fatigue.
Going beyond the neurological testing, both groups were also investigated for many common symptoms and illnesses. Those which were significantly more common in the chlordane exposed group included asthma, allergies, production of phlegm, chronic bronchitis by Medical Research Council criteria, and wheezing with and without shortness of breath. Headaches and indigestion were also more common among the chlordane exposed individuals.
In summary Dr. Kilburn and Thornton summarized their findings by stating,
The exposure of our study group appears to be from indoor air, due to the outgassing of chlordane from the wooden surfaces of the apartment complex... Examination of subjects exposed in their homes to chlordane as compared to referent subjects showed significant, and we suggest important, impairment of both the neurophysiological and psychological functions including mood states. Accompanying these changes were significant differences in symptom frequency and in respiratory rheumatic and cardiovascular disease symptoms. The most notable changes were slowing of reaction time, balance dysfunction as revealed by increased sway speed, reduction in cognitive function, perceptual motor speed, and immediate and delayed verbal recall... The neurobehavioral impairments measured in this environmental epidemiological study were similar to those noted in patients exposed to chlordane at home. These impairments include probably irreversible dysfunction of the brain. Possible effects on trigeminal nerve-pons-facial nerve function were suggested for the first time. Confirmatory studies, including follow-up after removal from exposure, are urgently needed. Meanwhile, chlordane use should be prohibited worldwide."
CHEM-TOX COMMENT: This study should generate heightened concern because of the large number of neurological and health effects seen at chlordane air levels of above 0.5m g/m3 (typical levels for most U.S. homes) and statements by researchers that developing children are harmed more by chemicals than adults. For more information on the chlordane problem and the health effects of living in a chlordane treated home - visit the chlordane web site by clicking this link.
Dr. Kaye H. Kilburn and John C. Thornton
SOURCE: Bulletin of Environmental Contamination Toxicology, 39:434-442, 1987
In the following study, researchers divided mice into three groups of ten mice each. Two groups were subjected to either a low or higher level of chlordane and the third group was used as a control group not exposed to any chlordane. After 30 days of daily exposure, the animals were sacrificed and the testicles were examined. The researchers stated that the chlordane exposed groups showed obvious changes to the part of the testicles where sperm development occurs (called the seminiferous tubules). Damaged tubules were present in 19% of the lower chlordane exposed animals - 31% of the higher chlordane exposed animals and only 3% in the animals not exposed to chlordane. There was also a reduction in the seminiferous tubule diameter in the higher chlordane exposed group. More details of this research can be seen at the infertility web site
Dr. K. J. Balash, M. A. Al-Omar, et al.
SOURCE: Journal of Toxicology and Environmental Health; 28 (4). 1989. 407-414
A case-control study of household dogs was conducted to determine if exposure to sidestream cigarette smoke and chemicals in the home, use of topical insecticides, and obesity are associated with the occurrence of bladder cancer. Information was obtained by interview from owners of 59 dogs with transitional-cell carcinoma of the bladder and 71 age- and breed size-matched control dogs with other chronic diseases or neoplasms. Bladder cancer risk was unrelated to sidestream cigarette smoke and household chemical exposures. Risk was significantly increased by topical insecticide use. When dogs were given 1-2 topical pesticide applications per year, there was a 60% increased risk of bladder cancer. When animals were given more than 2 pesticide applications per year there was a 3.5 times increased risk for the animal developing bladder cancer (chitrend; p = .008). This risk was enhanced in overweight or obese dogs. Further studies of this canine model may facilitate identification of specific carcinogens present in insecticides commonly used on pet animals and in the environment.
Department of Pathobiology
SOURCE: Journal of the American
Veterinary Medicine Association, April 15, 2004.
A study that links lawn chemicals to bladder cancer in Scottish terriers could help shed light on whether they cause cancer in some people, U.S. researchers said on Tuesday.
Purdue University researchers surveyed 83 owners of Scottish terriers whose pets had recently been diagnosed with bladder cancer for their report, published in the Journal of the American Veterinary Medicine Association.
"The risk ... was found to be between four and seven times more likely in exposed animals," said Larry Glickman, professor of epidemiology and environmental medicine in Purdue's School of Veterinary Medicine.
"While we hope to determine which of the many chemicals in lawn treatments are responsible, we also hope the similarity between human and dog genomes will allow us to find the genetic predisposition toward this form of cancer found in both Scotties and certain people."
Glickman and his colleagues earlier found that Scotties are about 20 times more likely to develop bladder cancer than other breeds.
"These dogs are more sensitive to some factors in their environment," Glickman said in a statement. "As pets tend to spend a fair amount of time in contact with plants treated with herbicides and insecticides, we decided to find out whether lawn chemicals were having any effect on cancer frequency."
The National Cancer Institute says about 38,000 men and 15,000 women are diagnosed with bladder cancer each year. Humans and animals often share genes that can predispose them to cancer.
"If such a gene exists in dogs, it's likely that it exists in a similar location in the human genome," Glickman said. "Finding the dog gene could save years in the search for it in humans and could also help us determine which kids need to stay away from lawn chemicals."
Glickman's team plans to survey children, as well as dogs, in households that have treated lawns and compare the chemicals in their urine samples with those from households with untreated lawns.
"It's important to find out which lawn chemicals are being taken up by both children and animals," he said.
SOURCE: Winnipeg CBC News - June 7, 2004
WINNIPEG - Doctors at a weekend conference in Winnipeg say there is a disturbing trend when it comes to the rising rate of certain cancers. They say pesticides are to blame for the increase – especially in childhood cancers. Steve Rauh chairs the environment committee for the Social Planning Council of Winnipeg. He says 70 per cent of the toxins we are exposed to come from the foods we eat. He wants to see policy changes that would encourage organic farming. "Our department of agriculture does not provide the kind of support to organic farming that it ought to be providing," he says. The Canadian Association of Physicians for the Environment has taken a strong position against municipalities using pesticides. It has also written papers on climate change.